Game shopping

My game shopping has curtailed this past year, partly because gaming time has been limited, partly because my budget has been limited.  Thus, if I’m to get myself a belated Christmas / early birthday present (that still isn’t certain), I have to be selective.  In particular, I’d like people to give feedback, especially people I’ve been gaming with, since I’d rather not buy something that ends up getting no table time.  In some particular order:

  • A Dominion expansion, likely Dominion: Prosperity or Dominion: Intrigue.  Pros – Dominion has been a pretty reliable game: easy to teach, holds up under repeated play.  Adding Seaside at least doubled the fun factor of the base set, so adding another expansion probably will do the same.  Cons – Dominion, um, dominance of game nights will probably continue or increase.
  • Race for the Galaxy plus any expansions I feel like.  Pros – It’s like San Juan, but with more variety, which is important since I think San Juan has a dominant strategy, and that makes it boring.  Cons – I already have San Juan and it’s big brother, Puerto Rico.
  • Battlestar Galactica.  Pros – Really, this is the game I should have bought instead of Shadows Over Camelot for that cooperative game (think Pandemic) but with a traitor (think Pandemic but someone is secretly sabotaging the team) niche.  The game has held up much better than SoC.  It plays like the first season of the show (you know, the good season): the last humans just getting by while paranoia spreads about cylons in their midst.  Cons – Unless the Cylons win early, the game will take 3 hours.  This is not something that will spontaneously be brought out at game nights; we’ll have to organize nights to play it.
  • 7 Wonders.  Pros – It’s something different: over the usual building a resource economy engine type of game we’re used to, layered on top is a drafting mechanic to choose what cards go in your civ (and not in your neighbors).  Also, it fill an important gap of allowing up to 7 players while still playing in about 30 minutes.  How many times have we had 5-6 players and spent another 15 minutes trying to split people into 2 games…  Cons – It came out pretty recently, so it may have some new game hype surrounding it, and availability is limited.
  • Yomi.  Pros – It’s a fighting game (like Street Fighter) but in card form.  Games are short, about 20 minutes.  The heart of the game is reading the position and your opponent and your opponent’s hand and picking the right card (think rock paper scissors, but each player has 13 unique cards, not all available at once).  The designer is a former fighting game tournament champion, so he knows the genre, and extensive playtesting has made sure that none of the various pairings are significantly imbalanced.  Cons – It’s only 2-player.  Also, since the designer is running his own independent game company, it’s more expensive than mainstream games, and I may not be able to afford many characters.
  • Edit: StarCraft II.  Knew I forgot something.

3 thoughts on “Game shopping

  1. I figured I’ll just chime in something for everything on the list:

    @Dominion Exp. – Yesssssss although you’re right about the con… and sometimes I wanna try something else instead of getting crushed by Kevin’s magic…

    @Race for the Galaxy – Ever since I heard richard dore (my old math gsi) playing it in the math lounge I wanted to try. So… yes on that one too.

    @Battlestar Galactica – Eh… wasn’t particularly fond of the show. Dunno how much that’ll influence my enjoyment, but makes me less inclined to want to play it.

    @7 Wonders – Intrigued and would like to try. I like innovation…. when I’m winning. >.<

    @Yomi – eh… We mostly play games FOR game nights, not for competitive-ness or anything so I think the appeal would be moderately lost…

    @Starcraft II – YES! But since now Alex, Alice, Kevin, and I (and I think michael and some rookies and probably others) all have it, we should set aside SC2 nights separately from board game nights or we'll end up playing some weird SC2 dominion mix and that would be…. either extremely bad or extremely awesome.

    The end ^^

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s